The Best of the Caribbean
The Guanaja Resorts List
West peak inn - we dont have a website for them you can find reviews on trip advisor here
Coral Bay Dive Resort
Go it alone with a vacation rental - they can offer you a more home like experience and you will get as much local knowledge as you need. Its a great option for all the islands and here also. If you want to dive you dont need a resort, so dont let that deter you.